Cruise Lines Caught in the Wake of the Carnival Triumph Incident Based on Latest Harris Poll

A new poll published today by Harris Interactive shows a decline in the top cruise line’s Quality, Trust & Purchase Intent scores in the aftermath of the February 10, 2013, engine room fire onboard the Carnival Triumph which resulted in the ship being be towed back to Mobile, Alabama.

As one would expect, Carnival Cruise Line’s Quality, Trust & Purchase Intent scores did drop, an average of 16%, in the poll recorded the week after the Carnival Triumph returned to Mobile. However, other top cruise lines, including Disney Cruise Line, seem to have been affected based the results of this latest survey.  The Harris Poll surveyed 2,230 adults familiar with each cruise line, and compared the results to a similar survey taken before the incident.

Harris Poll #11 Cruise Brand Perceptions March 2013

Overall, Disney Cruise Line was in line with the 7-Cruise Line average in each category.   The results placed Disney with the second highest drop in the Quality category, but the lowest drop in the purchase intent category.  I am left scratching my head.  The perceived quality of a Disney Cruise has decreased, but the intent to purchase does not reflect this mindset.  Notably, Holland America saw a 6% drop in perceived quality, but a 1% increase in intend to purchase.

After seeing the scores for Holland America and Disney Cruise Line, I think the key factor indicator in this study is the purchase intent.  Quality and trust in a cruise line are important, but it ultimately comes down to a person’s willing to book that future cruise.

Over half of Americans (53%) agree that they’re less likely to take a cruise now than they were a year ago, though this sentiment appears to be stronger among those who have never taken a cruise (58%) than among those who have (43%) – indicating that long term impacts from this incident could hit first-time cruise sales the hardest. – Harris Poll #11 March 4, 2013

Based on results of this survey, I would say Carnival and Norwegian will have to do the most of the grunt work to improve the overall perception of the cruise industry.  If you exclude those lines from the purchase intent the average drops in half to -3%.  At the end of the day, Carnival Cruise Line took a hit, as expected, in the public opinion polls with the rest of the industry simply getting caught up in the wake.

What do you think?  Did the Carnival Triumph incident impact your cruise plans?

One Reply to “Cruise Lines Caught in the Wake of the Carnival Triumph Incident Based on Latest Harris Poll”

  1. Janelle

    Heck no! That is like not flying after an incident on a plane. This is life and while I think Disney strives to do their best, humans work for them and as humans, we make mistakes. I am rather surprised this even affected other cruise lines at all. People and mass media…guess you have to take the good with the bad.


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.