Cookies BBQ Buffet Menu

Castaway Cay’s Cookies BBQ & Cookies Too BBQ Buffet Lunch Menu

Up first is a look at the offerings from the sliced fruit stand and Cookie’s BBQ on Castaway Cay.

June 2021 Gluten Free Version | Last verified April 2022

All Grilled Items are Served on Gluten-free Bread

  • Honey and Bourbon Glazed Seared Salmon Filet on BBQ Collard Greens
  • Cajun Spiced Rotisserie Chicken rubbed with Paprika, Oregano, Chili, Garlic marinated for 24 hours
  • St Louis Style BBQ Pork Spare Ribs with Sweet and Spicy BBQ Sauce and finished on the Char-grill
  • Chargrilled Hot Dogs with Caraway and Riesling Wine Sauerkraut
  • Flame Grilled Cheese Burgers/ Hamburgers
  • “Plant Based” BBQ Chicken Sandwich with Red Onion. Tomato and Escarole
  • Slow Cooked Vegetarian Bean Chili Black Bean, BBQ Baked Beans, Garbanzo Beans, Bell Peppers, Kidney Beans, Tomato, Celery, Onion, Garlic, Oregano and Basil simmered on the Chargrill


  • Coleslaw Shredded White Cabbage, Carrots and Onions tossed in Pineapple Syrup
  • Red Skin Potato Salad with Dijon Mustard, Hard chopped Egg Wholegrain Mustard dressing and Green Onions
  • Grilled Sweetcorn Salad with Avocado, White, Black and Fava Beans with a Lime Cilantro Dressing
  • Steamed Corn on the Cobb
  • Steamed Jasmine Rice
  • Vegetable Chips


  • Rice Dream Ice Cream
  • All Spiced Carrot Cake
  • Gluten Free Cookies

Past Versions of the Gluten Free Cookies BBQ Buffet Menu Menu

DCL Menu Castaway Cay Cookies BBQ Lunch November May 2020